[NC] [NC] Can a parent regain custody after giving up rights?

Lexi, Chatbot

I understand your concern. Can you tell me more about the circumstances surrounding your daughter’s mom signing over her rights and leaving the state?

Lexi, Chatbot

Have there been any recent developments or changes in the situation that may impact the custody arrangement?

Lexi, Chatbot

Is there anything else the family lawyer should know before i connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your custody issue.

Brandon

Hi there and welcome to AskALawyer. My name is Brandon and I’m an attorney. I’d be happy to help you today.

Please note that this discussion is for guidance only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Also, I’m human — I may need to research before responding and might be helping other clients at the same time, so thank you for your patience.

If more than 30 minutes pass, feel free to message me again!

What, if any, steps have you taken so far?

Brandon

1. The mother’s attempt to undo the custody transfer
   It sounds like your daughter’s mother voluntarily signed over her parental rights — or at least significant custody rights — to your parents.

In North Carolina, any custody or guardianship arrangement formalized by a court order carries legal weight. Simply claiming “I didn’t understand” isn’t usually enough to undo it — she’d need credible proof of duress, coercion, or incapacity.

She’s invoking Chapter 50 of North Carolina law, which governs child custody and visitation. The court’s primary focus will be the best interests of the child.

She would need to show that modifying the existing arrangement serves your daughter’s best interests better than her current, long-standing situation.

2. Your daughter’s established home and stability
   You have a strong case because your daughter has been living in North Carolina with you and your parents for years. Courts prioritize continuity and stability.

Judges will consider:

• How long the child has lived in her current home

• Her bond with you and her grandparents

• Who has been her primary caregiver

• Her schooling and community ties

• Each parent’s ability to meet her needs

You putting her to bed nightly, paying for daycare, and supporting her financially reinforces stability — a huge factor in your favor.

3. Past incidents of concern
   The previous safety incidents — her dislocated arm and the anaphylaxis episode — are relevant. They speak to concerns about her mother’s ability to respond appropriately in emergencies.

Courts take these issues seriously when assessing whether a parent can safely assume primary custody.

4. The mother’s desire to relocate to Florida
   In North Carolina, relocation cases are challenging.

A parent seeking to move a child out of state must prove the move is in the child’s best interest — not just more convenient for the parent.

Since your daughter is about to start kindergarten and has deep roots with you and your parents, the court will likely view relocation skeptically.

5. Your next steps
   Because you already have a lawyer, here’s how to strengthen your position:

• Gather documentation: Copies of all signed custody paperwork and court orders.

• Compile evidence of your involvement: Daycare receipts, support payments, daily routines.

• Document stability: School and daycare letters, medical records, statements from teachers or neighbors.

• Include prior safety concerns: Medical or police reports if available.

• Likelihood of her gaining sole custody
  Given your daughter’s established life in North Carolina and your active parenting role, it would be very difficult for her mother to convince a judge to uproot your daughter.

Courts heavily favor stability and continuity, and the burden is on the parent seeking the change to prove it’s beneficial.

That said, it’s important to stay consistent, avoid emotional disputes, and let your lawyer present your case through documentation and facts.

• Stay calm and child-focused: Demonstrate cooperation and consistency.

Brandon

If you don’t mind sharing a bit more, could you clarify:

• What specific paperwork did her mother sign — guardianship, custody, or termination of parental rights?

• Has she filed an official motion to modify custody yet, or is she still threatening to do so?

• Have there been any prior findings about her parenting or involvement with child protective services?

These details can help pinpoint how strong your position is legally.

Brandon

1. Nature of signing over parental rights
   The fact that both of you signed over your parental rights (or custody) to your parents is significant. North Carolina courts only approve such orders after careful review to ensure both parties understand the implications.

It sounds like it was a custody or guardianship transfer, not a full termination of rights. That means she still has limited residual rights but must prove that changing custody now serves your daughter’s best interests.

2. Stability of your daughter’s home
   Your daughter has lived most of her life in North Carolina, surrounded by you and her grandparents.

Her mother’s unstable living situation — moving between relationships or her sister’s house — will weigh heavily against her in court.

Given your daughter is about to start kindergarten, the court will be reluctant to disrupt her stability and established routine.

3. Visitation history
   You’ve shown flexibility and fairness. Allowing her mother extra time before she tried to take your daughter out of state demonstrates your good faith.

Once she made that threat, you were right to enforce the formal custody terms. Courts generally disapprove of any parent attempting to remove a child across state lines without permission.

4. Legal standards
   To change custody, your daughter’s mother must prove:

• A substantial change in circumstances, and

• That a new custody order would be in your daughter’s best interest.

From what you’ve described, neither condition is met.

5. How to strengthen your case further

• Keep all custody paperwork and court orders handy.

• Maintain records of her residence stability (or instability).

• Collect letters from teachers, daycare, or medical providers confirming your daughter’s thriving environment.

• Keep logs of visitations and communications.

Your lawyer will likely respond to her petition with a motion to dismiss or enforce the current custody order.

The evidence will show:

• Your daughter’s stability,

• Lack of substantial change, and

• Likelihood of her mother getting sole custody
  The likelihood appears low unless she can prove a major, positive change in her life and that removing your daughter from North Carolina would somehow be better for her.

Simply regretting her original decision is not enough.

Your best move:

• Keep following the current order,

• Stay calm and focused,

• Let your lawyer lead with evidence and professionalism.

• Risks posed by relocation

Brandon

Did you understand my answer, and did it address your concerns?

Feel free to add me to your favorites — whenever you have a new question, start a new thread or request me by name: @BrandonEsq.